Lokpal Bill Public Consultation

Pankaj Aggarwal Says:
# A3502LB June 8th, 2011 at 12:09 am

If anti-corruption agencies CBI, CVC and departmental vigilance are kept separate then each one of them will keep working on the same case on their own and their investigations do not match and there is clash between them. Also each of them work on the same case on their own which takes double the effort and money reqiured. So if they are merged into Lokpal they will work together saving the effort and money required and also avoid clashes.
During the investigations the accused (officials or ministers or any one else) try to threaten or bribe the
whistleblowers and the complainants, and also try to destroy evidence and hamper the investigation and turn it
in their favour. So if during the investigaton Lokpal begin to find evidence substantiating the allegation, Lokpal
and Lokayukta should have the powers to get the accused dismissed or suspended so that they can effectively
investigate further. The accused persons can threaten or bribe the whistleblowers and the complainants even while they are dismissed or suspended so Lokpal should also protect the whistleblowers and the complainants and keep a watch on them.
Hence Lokpal and Lokayukta can work effectively and people can trust them.

Sumit Pawa Says:
# A3501LB June 8th, 2011 at 12:08 am

The complaint reporting system for LOKPAL should me made available online right from the start, Of-course the people reporting it will have to provide their personal details for identification in online complaint to prevent fraud. So that people facing corruption problems dont see reporting it as a bigger problem and they shouldnt get laidback about it. There should also be an online database for realtime tracking of these complaints to keep everything transparent.

I am with anybody & everybody who takes a step against corruption.

ARUN BHUSHAN Says:
# A3500LB June 8th, 2011 at 12:08 am

SIR , THERE IS MAIN LEVEL OF CORRUPTION IS THE LOWER ONE AS EXAMPLE-A HAWALDAR IN DUTY AT ON HI-WAY HE TAKE MONEY OF SUCH A SMALL AMOUNT OF Rs-10 OR 20, IN THIS AMOUNT THERE IS A PART FROM HIS INSPECTOR TO CM.
I WANT TO SAY THAT NOT ONLY COMMON PERSON IS BUT THIS DEPARTMENTAL CORRUPTION HOW THIS IS WILL BE PUNISHED BY LOKPAL BECAUSE THERE IS NO COMPLAINER OVER THERE .
THIS IS FIRST
SECOND- U KNOW THAT THERE R MANY CASES BY POLICE WHICH IS BASE LESS BUT DUE TO POWER OF WRITING THEY DO WHICH THEY WANT TO DO , I WANT TO SAID MAKE SOME LOW ON THAT ,SO THE WRITING POWER OF THESE POLICE MAN R CAME TO UR LOKPAL ALSO ,THE POWER TO CUT IT AND PUNISHED IT .

THANK YOU
ARUN BHUSHAN
MOBILE- 09307708090

Pradee S Jodhani Says:
# A3496LB June 8th, 2011 at 12:01 am

Sir,
Please make more use of Word "Deemed" as its must for the act to be more effective and wide-spread its net against the guilty entities. Sir just a clarification is required, Whether there is any provision stating that act can attach property of both the parties? if there is any provision then General Public will be afraid of coming forward and filing complaints against curropt official/entities as everybody on this planet knows that in India there is a law/section/provision in collusion to the existing law/provision/section, which may work against the interest of public @ large.


Thanks a lot for such a Great Effort for freeing India from the Arms of Curroption.

Rahul Shrivastava Says:
# A3488LB June 7th, 2011 at 11:47 pm

Sir, we are working in Bhilai Steel Plant,SAIL Bhilai.Here we face a different type problem in departmental promotion from nonexecutive to executive cadre our management first time introduce written+interview exam.
In policy they say that it depend on merit but when final result came it was just opposite to that, those who got
90-95% marks are out and those got 60-75% marks are selected(more than 90%curruption in selection). Every door what appear in our mind like cvc,high court, rti, cbi we reached there. In high court not any single hearing was happen in two years . Central rti(cic) direct the management to show the omr sheet but they didnt obey.CBI raided Bokaro unit but chargesheet not filed.Lastly we met Mrs Arti Bajpai(IAC-CG) ,but how to contact you is still unanswered .Art 36 & 195 of company act 1956 is violeted .OMR sheet based exams transparancy not followed.
Interview was fixed.Court not reacted as magistrates are former SAIL lawyers(selected from bench).

Gourisankar Mandal. Says:
# A3483LB June 7th, 2011 at 11:41 pm

All money & property of a person should be ceased immediately after corruption is proved .
Such a person should not be allowed to hold a respnsible post in future , even political leadership.

Sanjay Maheshwari Says:
# A3481LB June 7th, 2011 at 11:36 pm

the publicservant once convicted should not be eligible to apply or hold any office or a elected representative should not be able to contest any election or hold any govt post

Kaushal Kumar Says:
# A3477LB June 7th, 2011 at 11:32 pm

Present Lokpal either drafted by Govt. or Civil Society is lacking in covering the root cause of corruption. it is focused on corruption by Lok- Sevak and not the other beneficiary, like in 2g how much Raja and other personnel get 10000 or 20000crs? who was the most beneficiary. Its telecom cos. When Raja like people seeing that due to power waisted in them people are earning lacs of crores Ruppees they become more corrupt. today we are seeing that businessmen involve in tax chori, corruption. jugadbaji getting faster growth and adopting unfair means in business in future. I think a provision in lokpal should be like this:
If prosecution in a corruption case is succeded
1. the person / company other than loksevak involved in any kind should be banned for any kind public dealing.
2. in case of proven charges, the amount earned by the company through unfair means should deposited/ recovered within 3months after final judgement. or the company should be auctioned and loss to public money should be recovered. loss made to public money by loksevak should be recovered from his property.
3. both should be prosecuted against criminal case.

i also think the companies earning profit more than 10-20% should also to be bring under the ambit of lokpal bill because it can only be done by over- prising. i residing in a mid size city and can estimate that what govt is getting from this city from various taxes is only 1% of tax chories made by business person. no businessmen is giving bill. there are two bill book , kachhi and pakki. but all this is going on. Charted accountant and legal consultant are assisting them is tax chories. i think that if a tax theft case is prooved against a person there should be provision
1. the firm should pay the difference of tax due since its establishment.
2. the CA / tax consultent should be banned and 10% of tax chori to recovered from him.
3. CBI/ TAX authorities at least upto joint commissioner level should also be charge sheeted for any kind of tax chori for their failure in timely detection of such case.

i think the corruption in private sector is much more than govt sector. i estimate it 10-90 ratio and ultimately loss to public money. thus i suggest that following point to be bring under corruption and thus under lokpal
1. overpricing
2. tax chori.
3.recovery of any undue amount by any person of society.

Azhar Says:
# A3473LB June 7th, 2011 at 11:29 pm

There should be a provision that the Government/ any courts other than supreme court will not interfere in any proceedings of lokpal neither through bringing any ordinance / stay order to stall, prohibit or restrain the action initiated/order made under the Jan Lokpal Bill nor bring any ordinance / stay order to stall, prohibit or restrain any provision of the Jan Lokpal Bill.

Mitul Vora Says:
# A3471LB June 7th, 2011 at 11:26 pm

बहुत बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद एक बड़े नेक काम करने के लिए हम भी आपके साथे है.में सुचन देना चाहूँगा की लोकपाल बिल में एक इसी व्यवस्था की जाये जिसमे एक नेशनल सेंट्रली कॉल सेंटर बनाया जाये जिसके जरिये किसीभी नागरिक को भ्रस्ट्राचार के बारे में पता लगे तो तुरंत वो लोकपाल कमिटी को इन्फोर्म कर सके.और लोकपाल कमिटी उन छोटे से लेकर बड़े होदे वाले लोग तक पहुँच सके.
इस देस में मेंरे हिसाब से जयादा भ्रस्त्रचारी पोलिसे ही है उसके लिए यदि कोई पोलिसे भ्रस्त्रचरी पकडे जाये तो उसको कड़ी सजा और सीबीआई जिसका बुरा इस्तेमाल सभी केस में करके सरकार अपने लोगो को बचा लेती है.उसमे भी सीबीआई के लिए भी कुछ कड़े कानून बन जायेगे तो सिस्टम को भ्रस्त्रच्रआर से मुक्त कर सकते है.